"Do you actually care about truth or just science? Do you actually - TopicsExpress



          

"Do you actually care about truth or just science? Do you actually want to say and defend that your moral conclusions are true or just your feelings? And if they are just your feelings, then why are you in such a lather about religious people who live by their religions because of their irrational feelings based on fictions when by your own super-”knowing” and cynical understanding your own moral judgments are just irrational feelings based on fictions? You get furious that Leah would side with an abominable institution like the Catholic Church but when pressed you say there really is not objectivity or rationality to a moral judgment like that. “That’s just your subjective feelings.” So how exactly are you good hard-nosed “rationalists” again when you self-conceive yourself as pressuring someone over what amount to only your feelings and not rationally binding and defensible reasons to think you’re right and she’s wrong? On your interpretation ethics is you doing what you feel like works for you but you also think there is no objectivity to that judgment. But you do not entitle religious people to do what feels like will work for them because why? Their judgments are not objective? According to you, neither are yours! So, tell me and tell Leah, since you treat realists like us with such spitting contempt. Why do you choose to be so irrational?" patheos/blogs/camelswithhammers/2012/06/how-foolish-atheists-convinced-the-atheist-blogger-leah-libresco-that-catholic-philosophy-was-rationally-superior-to-atheism/ Camels With Hammers (Daniel Fincke)
Posted on: Sun, 30 Jun 2013 08:29:26 +0000

Trending Topics



Recently Viewed Topics




© 2015