Can America defeat China in a war? Big88ham Answered Last The U.S. will never be able to defeat China strategically or in the long run. History has told us that the U.S. has failed to defeat China in all past engagements since WW2, directly or indirectly, and when China had far inferior hardware and doctrines than now. China will be fighting a defensive war, no one will be willing to help an aggressor in the international community. The only U.S. allies which will actively assist will only be Japan. The U.K. will only provide limited support -- if she ever opts for fighting China. No E.U. country will help. Russia will of course not help the U.S., and is likely to provide intelligence and supplies to China. China and Russia will also veto any unfavourable bill in the United Nations. The U.S. will be fighting alone. The war will be fought right at Chinas doorsteps, without land-based supply bases, the U.S. will have serious logistics problems to launch any offensive to the Chinese Mainland with reasonable results. The U.S. is virtually broke and running on borrowed money, no one can fight such a large scale war by just printing more cash. The U.S. cannot afford the attrition of her high-priced military hardware in a high rate and for a long time, fighting China will certainly mean high attrition rate and for a long time. China tops the foreign reserves chart and is also U.S. largest creditor, if say the U.S. tries to win the war by destroying Chinas economy, then I am afraid China will win instead. A new term of China freezes U.S. overseas assets will emerge. And dont even dream of changing the Chinese ruling government by such a war, as if war really breaks out the whole Chinese nation will be against just one single enemy -- the United States. This has happened against the Japanese during WW2, when the Communists and Nationalists were fighting each other. Yet if the question is Can China defeat America in a war?, then the answer is also no. Yes I agree with the answer below USA CAN DEFEAT CHINA, i just want to complete this answer. United States absolutely can defeat China in War. It is correct that China have a large number of soldier but its still useless because their technology in military still old like in 1970. In this era, war is cant be determine by a large number of soldier but how to increase the casualties by using a small number of soldier. Now we can look at any aspect : Warship China have a lot of warship than US have, but all China warship is Tiny and its outdated. US Navy is the largest nave (tonnage wise) in the world, and still bigger than next 17 largest navies combined. Talk about China anti ship missiles and anti ballistic missiles for Mid-Air, China Anti Ship Missiles its usless agains US Battleship group because its very easy for United States to track and shooting down all missiles can threat the battlegroup. Satellite and Missiles China Anti Ballistic Missile for Mid-Air that has successfully tested this week, it is true these missiles interceptor is effective to track and shooting down mid-air ballistic missile but only ballistic conventional missile such as russia ballistic missile or India ballistic missile but China Mid-Air Anti Ballistic Missile cannot shooting down the US Cruise or Ballistic Missile because US Cruise and Ballistic Missile has upgrade many times the technology inside the missiles so its very difficult for China to track and shooting down US Missiles. Now USA has Missile Shield which is can track down and shooting down all Ballistic Missile including ICBM (Intercontinental Ballistic Missile) and US Still Developing and upgrade the system with Japan. China is 3rd Country in the world that have Anti Satellite Missiles but even though China has that missiles and want to shooting down US Satellites, its very easy for US to intercept China Anti Satellite Missile before hit the target. Aircraft Combat China air plane doesnt match with F-22, F-35, or F15 Strike eagle even though in magazine they said they have the next generation aircraft but still cannot match, we can see all china product that is very easily damage. and the most important is China doesnt have Top Gun and Experience Pilot in Real Combat, they just have pilot that good in Simulation. Submarine it is true that china has a lot of Submarine right now and has a nuclear submarine, but still the technology still old and its very easy for United States to track and sink china submarine. US Subs has the most update technology and now US Subs can be stealth or cannot be track by any country in this world. Soldier and Special Forces China has a lot of Soldier in the world because China population around 1.6 billion right now, but still useless again high impact technology, and China soldier doesnt has experience in real war, its different with US Soldiers that have many experience in real war. Just Flashback in Korean War 1950, China drop more than 500.000 soldier to help North Korean, in the beginning China had success take control pyongyang and pushed back UN Soldier back to Seoul which is in that time the Supreme Commander for UN at the Far East is General Mac Arthur. at the end of war China has lost over 700.000 men and US Soldier has lost around 50.000. Technology China technology still out of date like technology in 1970. for example China production motorcycle and car, but its very easy to broken and need to repair many times and it takes a lot of cost, and China doesnt have High Tech Semiconductor Chip Factory so they need to import from another country like Japan. Radar united States has the most high tech radar in the world more than any country, so its impossible for China to track down US Stealth Air Plane, only US Radar can detect. Main Battle Tank (MBT) China MBT like usually still out of dated, they have MBT t-72 model and it doesnt match with US MBT : M1A2 Abraam which is has high tech technology inside, has very strong armor and use 120 mm Cannon with Uranium Composition and making only US in the world use this type of Cannon in MBT. Helicopter China Helicopter is very similar with Russian Helicopter Hind because China has adopted the technology from Russia, but its very not comparable with US Chopper AH-64D Apache Longbow which is very famous in battle. If China and US going into war over Taiwan, there is a strategy to win this war : 1. US must make secure all their base in pacific especially in Japan and South Korea from China attack and must fully protect because this base is foundation to send more troops from USA and as a base supply. 2. US must supply Taiwan with a lot of High-Tech Weapon, Aircraft and Military Necessary, so Taiwan can be defend it self from All China Ballistic Missiles and All China aircraft and help US while US fight with China 3. China First Step to strike is attack US Base and Navy Battle group, so US must be ready for this, US must be strike first if US has seen the sign of movement China Warship approaching Taiwan or US Battle Group. US must be disobey the Rules of Engagement. US must mobilize half of US Navy Warship into this war to win the battle at Sea. 4. Once US has neutralized all China Warship at sea, the next move is US Must Strike China with a lot of High Tech Short Range Ballistic Missile and high speed Cruise Missiles ( The most important Target on China that must destroyed is Radar Station, Ballistic Missile Battery, Tank Factory, Aircraft Factory, Power Plant, Radio Station, Television Station, Bridge), For example, if US want to destroyed the power plant , US must strike with over 15 cruise missile in 1 target and it makes china difficult to shooting the missiles because their capability for anti ballistic missile still primitive and limited. If all the target has destroyed and it takes a very expensive cost to china, i think china will withdraw from this war. Just Remember : China Must Strike First Taiwan or US Property at the beginning, so there is reason for US to engage China, and i think all US Allies will Support US. If US Want to defeat China in Economics, US and US-ALLIES must be impose the regulation for Import products from China, US and his Allies must us protecsionism regulation to protect all US and his Allies Products from China Product, and because of that China Export will be dropped shortly, because China cannot stand hold just depend on their Internal Consume. If US win over China in all aspect, US Must act now and dont political talk to much, Dont Afraid to China because Economic Interest. USA Must do Something Real to China that USA and His Allies is very very strong. Short answer, yes. China does not have the naval or air power to match the United States, which is in a class of its own. There is a reason why the carrier groups are feared and China is rushing for its own. We could attack and acquire specific designated objectives, possibly indefinately, though occupying such a country is manifestly impossible. While occupation is mutually impossible, we could invite destruction upon their coastal cities, which consequently is where their economic power lies. They could not presently do the same to us. Even taking allies into account, the United States currently has the advantage with a number of allies or possible allies close to encircling China, and certainly able to cut off its vital maritime trade. If the objective is to destroy China as an economic power, yes If the objective is to generate a change in government, a good chance. If the objective is to occupy China NO. 33 people found this useful Was this answer useful? Yes Somewhat No
Posted on: Fri, 03 Oct 2014 22:36:56 +0000