How-low-can-you-sink department (Obama division): The always superb Charlie Savage reports at the New York Times today that the Obama administration is considering reaffirming a Bush administration ruling that the United Nations Convention Against Torture does not apply to prisoners held by the U.S. abroad. Once upon a time, as with so much else, Obama was against the Bush interpretation of U.S. obligations or lack of them under the treaty (which helped open the way to CIA torture in black sites and elsewhere abroad). Now, maybe not so much. In other words, while the president has ruled out torture abroad, this reading, if agreed to within the administration, would weaken a global standard against torture and abuse. Its truly a sorry possibility. Tom When the Bush administration revealed in 2005 that it was secretly interpreting a treaty ban on “cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment” as not applying to C.I.A. and military prisons overseas, Barack Obama, then a newly elected Democratic senator from Illinois, joined in a bipartisan protest. Mr. Obama supported legislation to make it clear that American officials were legally barred from using cruelty anywhere in the world. And in a Senate speech, he said enacting such a statute acknowledges and confirms existing obligations under the treaty, the United Nations Convention Against Torture. But the Obama administration has never officially declared its position on the treaty, and now, President Obama’s legal team is debating whether to back away from his earlier view. It is considering reaffirming the Bush administration’s position that the treaty imposes no legal obligation on the United States to bar cruelty outside its borders, according to officials who discussed the deliberations on the condition of anonymity. The administration must decide on its stance on the treaty by next month, when it sends a delegation to Geneva to appear before the Committee Against Torture, a United Nations panel that monitors compliance with the treaty. That presentation will be the first during Mr. Obama’s presidency. nytimes/2014/10/19/us/politics/obama-could-reaffirm-a-bush-era-reading-of-a-treaty-on-torture.html
Posted on: Sun, 19 Oct 2014 16:00:00 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015