I wrote this is response to some idiotic comments on a perfectly - TopicsExpress



          

I wrote this is response to some idiotic comments on a perfectly lovely post over at The Alpha Parent (the one about the moth): Reasonable people understand that "in nature," without intervention, sometimes mothers and babies die, who could have been saved if they’d had access to modern medical care. They also understand that Western medicine has gone way beyond “medically necessary” interventions to the point that modern ob/gyn/labor&delivery care now causes as much – if not more -- damage than it does good. One of the problems with a rational evaluation of the topic is that it’s easy to say “A child’s life was saved by intervention” and place some sort of value on that. It’s not so easy to place a value on the hundreds of thousands [millions?] of children whose lives were permanently harmed by unnecessary c-sections, unnecessary separation from mother, unnecessary interventions such as routine fetal heart monitoring, epidurals, early cord cutting, suctioning, hatting, swaddling, vigorous scrubbing baths, immediate eye drops, immediate circumcision, formula supplementation, etc. etc. etc. How does one begin to do the math? If we harm 10,000 children to various degrees, is that worth it to save the life of one child? What if we harm 100,000 children through our interventions, but save the life of one child? There is no way to compare the outcomes. But there is no shame is asking medical professionals to rethink how they approach childbirth, to dial back the interventions and use them only when medically necessary or when proven to be helpful, rather than harmful. “Evidence-based medicine” that relies on current research tells us that all of the interventions mentioned above (routine fetal heart monitoring, epidurals, early cord cutting, etc.) do NOT lead to improved outcomes in terms of maternal-child health. On the contrary, they are harmful. Yet they too often remain part of “traditional Western childbirth practice” – even against the mother’s wishes.
Posted on: Mon, 10 Jun 2013 20:55:01 +0000

Trending Topics



Recently Viewed Topics




© 2015