Vi propongo un estratto di una recensione di Into the Dalek che puntualizza alcuni elementi dellepisodio per illuminare, a mio avviso, soprattutto chi il Capaldis Doctor fatica/non riesce/non vuole inquadrarlo nella giusta luce. Phil Ford and Steven Moffat also use their script to further examine the Twelfth Doctor’s character […] When the Doctor asks Clara for an answer that is “honest, cold, and considered, without kindness or restraint” – words that could never have described the Eleventh Doctor – Ford and Moffat are actually defining this incarnation’s personality. These are his values, now, and they’re evidenced by the Doctor’s quips crossing from “careless” to “caustic.” However, despite his new demeanor, Into the Dalek demonstrates that the Doctor’s defining character traits remain the same, including his inherent desire to make people better. “No, no, come on. Not like that … Get it right,” he demands of Journey, even though she has a gun pointed at him, and is in shock over the loss of her brother. “Will you take me back to my ship … please?” she responds. This isn’t just a lesson in manners, but in conflict resolution, negotiation, and tempering violence. This is how the Doctor initially tries to solve problems, not with screwdriver-induced explosions, but with insight, and with words. Further, in the episode’s third act, the Doctor appeals to Journey’s humanity, reminding her that, “Soldiers take orders,” and encouraging her to think for herself. The Doctor: “A Dalek is a better soldier than you will ever be. You can’t win this way.” Journey: “So, what do we do?” The Doctor: “Something better.” That so much of Into the Dalek demonstrates the positive effect the presence of the Doctor has on others […] What a terrifically wasted opportunity! Journey has the best introduction and reason to join the TARDIS crew than anyone since Martha, and could have been the best example of a companion fulfilling the Doctor’s mantra of becoming extraordinary since Rose or Donna. Plus, her name is “Journey” – how is that not perfect for a companion? Mi trovo concorde anche di più a riguardo delloccasione persa con Journey. Cosa ne pensate di queste considerazioni? Chi fosse interessato a leggere larticolo per intero: doctorwhotv.co.uk/into-the-dalek-review-66213.htm?utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+DoctorWhoTv+%28Doctor+Who+TV%29
Posted on: Tue, 02 Sep 2014 13:11:39 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015