Washington (CNN) – If the findings of a new study on congressional speech levels represented their actions, senators would be busy passing notes in history class, while representatives attempted to trick the substitute trigonometry teacher. A new study by the Sunlight Foundation found that Congress speaks at an average grade level of 10.6, equivalent to a sophomore in high school. That number is down from 2005, when Congress 11.5 speaking level was in line with a high school junior. – Follow the Ticker on Twitter: @PoliticalTicker Lee Drutman and his colleagues at Sunlight took every word members of Congress said on the House and Senate floors between January 1996 and April 2012 and put them through the Flesch-Kincaid test, a tool that equates higher grade levels with longer words and sentences. Drutman found that while Democrats used to speak at a lower level then Republicans, in the last seven years, that trend has flipped. The bottom ten on the list was dominated by freshman Republicans. Of the ten, all were Republicans and eight were freshman. Rep. Mick Mulvaney, a Republican freshman from South Carolina, found himself at the bottom of all 535 members of congress with a 7.9 grade level. We do it on purpose, Mulvaney said of himself and his other freshman Republicans. People have been teaching this for decades. If you want someone to understand your message, you speak clearly and concisely. Mulvaney, who graduated with honors from Georgetown University and earned a law degree at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, disagreed with the idea that the declining speech level said anything about congressional intelligence. I dont think anyone equates the polysyllabic nature of your words as a substitute for intellect, Mulvaney said. Hemmingway wrote very clearly and concisely. Faulkner did not. It does not mean either was smarter than the other. While Drutman acknowledged the numbers speak for themselves, it is clear that both Democrats and Republicans have experienced a decline in speech level. What you see is that both parties have dropped off, Drutman said. It is certainly a bipartisan trend over all, Republicans have dropped a little more than Democrats but the trend is consistent across both parities. In 2007, both Republicans and Democrats spoke at an 11.1 grade level. Since then, Republicans have fallen to a 10.4 grade level, while Democrats have fallen to a 10.8 level. Earlier this year, President Barack Obamas State of the Union addressed scored below the current congressional average. As pointed out by the University of Minnesotas Smart Politics, the presidents 2012 State of the Union address earned an 8.4 grade level. This was not Obamas lowest rated speech; his 2011 State of the Union address earned an 8.1, the second lowest State of the Union address even given. With three addresses under his belt, President Obama has the lowest average Flesch-Kincaid score for State of the Union addresses of any modern president, read the University of Minnesota report. Obamas average grade-level score of 8.4 is more than two grades lower than the 11.1 grade average for the other 67 addresses written by his 12 predecessors. And while the average American speaks around an 8th or 9th grade reading level, some of historys most prominent documents were written at much higher levels. According to the Sunlight report, the Constitution was written at a 17.8 level, the Declaration of Independence at a 15.1 grade level and the Federalist Papers at a 17.1 level. Even the notably concise Gettysburg Address clocked in at an 11.2 grade level. Drutman said more moderate members of Congress speak at a higher grade level than more partisan Democrats and Republicans. Controlling for other factors, it is generally the most moderate members of both parties who speak at the highest grade levels, and the most extreme members who speak at the lowest grade levels, read the report. This pattern is most pronounced among freshmen and sophomore members. Not all members of Congress rated poorly, though. Rep. Dan Lungren, R-California, earned the highest overall rating with a 16.0 grade level. Sen. Daniel Akaka, D-Hawaii, earned a 14.2 rating, the highest among senators. Brett ODonnell, the president of ODonnell and Associates and a former debate coach for former Gov. Mitt Romney and Rep. Michelle Bachmann, R-Minnesota, said that while blame for this trend could be pinned on both the politicians and the state of education in the United States, he also blamed the media. The media frame drives the content and the media frame helps dumb down the content, ODonnell said. If you are going to give the candidates only 60 seconds, it will push them to give just a sound bite. ODonnell said that when prepping for a debate, you have to coach the candidate to keep their answers concise and within the time guidelines. According to ODonnell, the average amount of response time given to a candidate in 2012 was around 60 seconds. That debate brevity, he said, could have worked its way into congressional floor speeches. The fact that candidates get constrained … means the grade level will go down, ODonnell said. Drutman hypothesized similar reasons for the slipping grade levels. One reason perhaps you see the decline is members of Congress increasingly see their audience as YouTube, Drutman said. They arent quoting Shakespeare like they used to.
Posted on: Wed, 16 Jul 2014 08:41:53 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015