Mann Ki Baat With Obama, Tick. But What Else? (Dr. Shashi Tharoor is a two-time MP from Thiruvananthapuram, the Chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on External Affairs, the former Union Minister of State for External Affairs and Human Resource Development and the former UN Under-Secretary-General. He has written 14 books, including, most recently, Pax Indica: India and the World of the 21st Century.) As New Delhi braces itself for traffic gridlock during next weeks Republic day visit by President Barack Obama, the questions occupying the minds of those in our capital who think about Indo-US relations are much more about India than they are about the US. Will the visit prove to be, as Prime Minister Modis visit to Washington last September was universally considered, more about pageantry than substance? What can India get out of its distinguished American visitor, embarking, as all second-term Presidents in their last two years of office do, upon a lame-duck period of office, with a hostile Republican majority in Congress and a period of domestic stagnation ahead? A transactional element is bound to creep into a relationship that has never been short of photo-ops but has delivered little of big-ticket value since the spectacular adoption of the Indo-US nuclear deal by the UPA Government. When Prime Minister Modi went to the US, India had hoped for some announcement of American willingness to aid Indian defence production by offering state-of-the-art equipment to Indian manufacturers. None has been forthcoming. Since his return to New Delhi, Mr Modi has pushed for 49% FDI in defence. But is that enough to allure American manufacturers? And as long as his partys aberrant Hindutva politics prompts the Opposition to obstruct legislation to make such policy initiatives law, with what credibility will the PM assure American investors of a reliable and predictable environment for them to come in to? Travelling to New Delhi soon after concluding an agreement with Beijing committing the planets two biggest economies to concrete carbon-emission targets by 2030, Obama is likely to want to emerge with something similar from his visit here. Modis India, on the other hand, is in the early stages of a vigorous Make in India drive for enhanced manufacturing, which will prove incompatible with reducing emissions to make America happy. Can the contradiction be resolved on this visit? One way of squaring the circle would be through the transfer of environmentally-friendly green technologies from the US to India at an affordable price. This would help India to become more ecologically-conscious, in line with constant US exhortations, while putting American money (and technology) where its mouth is, and showing sceptical Indians how relations with the US can serve Indias direct vital national interests. Can we expect any concrete announcement about progress on this during President Obamas forthcoming visit? The diplomatic auguries are not too encouraging. Obviously, in terms of what India wants from the unprecedented attendance of a US President at the Republic Day parade, theres more than economics at stake. It is part of our foreign policy mantra to say that each of our bilateral relationships has little to do with any other country. But in fact China and Pakistan cannot be irrelevant to New Delhis courtship of Washington.After the snafu of President Xis visit to India last year, with Chinese troops insouciantly setting up camp on Indian soil, and renewed Chinese belligerence on issues of importance to India from Arunachal Pradesh to military installations in neighbouring countries, there is no doubt that a close strategic partnership with America will help stiffen Indias resistance to too much elbowing by its northern neighbour. While some analysts suggest that Indias outreach to Obama is a signal that it needs Americas military-industrial muscle on its side (to quote Chaitanya Kalbag), my own view is that confrontation with China is not in Indias interest. But Obamas taking the salute on Republic Day sends a signal to both China and Pakistan that India has a powerful friend in DC. Of course, when a US President expends the time and energy to visit a foreign country, he expects something out of it too. But on concrete issues where Americans want deliverables from India - removing barriers to trade and investment, easing the entry of US nuclear businesses and pharmaceutical companies - it is unclear how much Mr Modi can do to overcome resistance in the bureaucracy and the political class. On nuclear liability, notably, the onerous clauses in the current law had been introduced by his own party in Parliament. On pharma, Mr Modis surrender to American dictates had already been announced before he went there last year, much to the dismay of Indian patients who will now have to pay much for patented American medicines that they have been getting in generic form at a tenth the price. But if he hoped for some goodwill from his American visitor on that issue, the denial of a patent in India for a hepatitis-C drug by the US pharma company Gilead just before Obamas visit has queered the pitch, ensuring some tough talk between the delegations next week. One possible area of convergence between the two chief executives is their shared commitment to help translate Mr Modis promises of transforming Indias demographics into a major economic success story for a free-market democracy. Here President Obamas State of the Union address on Tuesday 20th January made some relevant points: 21st century businesses need 21st century infrastructure, he said, in words that sound like his Indian counterparts: modern ports, stronger bridges, faster trains and the fastest internet. Foreign policy could help: Obama exhorted his America to combine military power with strong diplomacy [and to] leverage our power with coalition building. This is where his outreach to India fits in. New Delhi will never become formally a part of any US-led coalition; our national prickliness will ensure that words like ally are never used, but partner could acquire a strategic dimension. Might New Delhi commit to more joint military exercises and military-technology agreements with the U.S.? That would be detail worth looking out for in any joint communique that might emerge from the Obama visit.Despite the lack of headline-making breakthroughs in recent years, Indo-US relations have typically hummed along most effectively beneath the surface - in dozens of working groups on co-operation in such areas as education and science and technology, and in continuing people-to-people exchanges across the board that give relations with the US a depth that our other bilateral relationships currently lack. The media will focus on feel-good stories like President Obamas joining Prime Minister Modis mann ki baat radio address, but it is really in these unspectacular ways that the real progress between New Delhi and Washington, DC is made. For anything bigger, Mr Modi and his team will have to work a lot harder for results than they have done so far.
Posted on: Thu, 22 Jan 2015 23:58:51 +0000
Trending Topics
Recently Viewed Topics
© 2015